Nintendo’s Rumored New System – Is it a Good or Bad Idea?

Wii

As we’ve posted earlier, speculation is aloft that Nintendo will be coming out with either an HD version of the Wii, or a new console all together.  Having only launched in November of 2006, the Wii is not even 5 years old yet.  This is still fairly young to middle aged as consoles are concerned nowadays.  The Nintendo GameCube lasted nearly 7 years before being discontinued, and the direct competition, Sony’s Playstation 2 has been around, and still supported (although barely) for 11 years.

So why the outs for the current Wii?  Here’s our take:

When the Wii first launched back in 2006, it was one of a kind.  It’s solution to motion controlled gaming was creative and elegant, and truly did set a trend for the future of gaming.  For those readers unfamiliar with how the Wii operates, here’s a basic explanation.  The sensor bar utilized by the Wii is named rather deceptively.  There is nothing even resembling any form of sensor actually built into that bar.  The sensor bar is actually a set of of 4 infrared light emitters (2 bulbs on each side).  You can confirm this yourself by pointing your cell phone camera at the sensor bar while it is on.  All of the work is done in the Wii remote itself.  When pointing the remote at the sensor bar, a camera built into the end of the remote (the large black portion on the front), is detecting those IR lights, to determine the controllers orientation, as well as its general altering position.  It can determine it’s orientation a little more accurately with the use of built in gyros as well.

As discussed in our motion control comparison article written months, back the Playstation Move and the Microsoft Kinect are far more advanced.  Due to the technology used in the Wii, the remote is little more than a glorified yard stick.  Pointing at the screen, your position in Z space is irrelevant.  The point you are pointing at will be hit in the same manner no matter where you stand, or what direction your remote is coming from.  Because the Move, and Kinect interpret 3D space in addition to motion, far more can be done with them.  This isn’t a fault of Nintendo’s.  Again, they tackled this system first, created an elegant solution to make it happen, but now without 3D depth detection, are pigeon holed into a very particular set of motion controlled gaming.  They simply cannot perform motion controls like the competitor anymore.  They are however still outselling, and are more well known for motion controlled gaming than its competitors.  Largely due to coming first, and doing it nearly 5 years longer than anyone else.

We want to hear your thoughts and ideas.  Is abandoning the Wii in favor of a new console  a good strategy?  The prospect of improved graphics, and possibly improved motion controls is nice, but this will force gamers and current Wii owners to prematurely buy a new system (remember, many people were unable to even find a Wii to purchase on a regular basis until 2 – 3 years ago) .  Leave some comments and let us hear what you think on the matter!